LP不好声是因为未搞好，CD不好声是因为搞不好！？ [复制链接]

正好看到一个关于BEACH BOYS - "Pet Sounds"这张专辑DCC公司发行的CD版本和LP版本哪个好声的讨论,正好混音师也在.里面有个玩家的发言,我比较赞同.

"I prefer the vinyl over the CD but it's not because the CD is inferior in any way. It's kind of an intangible thing. The CD presents the listener with an accurate representation of the master tape and a "clarity" that dictates a certain volume setting for optimum results. The LP (for lack of a better word) lacks that "clarity" present on the CD and as a result dictates a higher volume level setting (though not louder relative to the CD). This brings out more of the room acoustics and other nuances present in the recording which only helps the breath of life factor & it warms the heart more too.
I find this true on many but not all of the DCC releases I have exposure to. For instance I like the Miles Davis Fantasy OJC vinyl reissues better than their DCC gold CD counterparts for the reasons mentioned above."

另外一个玩家的说法,也赞同,虽然听上去有点像废话,但的确就是这么回事.

"They match tonally, which was the intent. If your vinyl rig sounds better than your CD player, then the LP will sound better. If your CD player sounds better than your vinyl rig, then the CD will sound better. Kinda stands to reason, eh?  

Beyond that and we're going to spiral into the LP vs CD debate, which is invariably an endless loop of opposing opinions. Sorta pointless."

整个讨论在下面,很短的.LP如何制作的,CD如何制作的,老实说,这如果不是由混音师自己告诉你,像我们一般玩家肯定无法得知.

http://www.stevehoffman.tv/forums/showthread.php?t=64649

felixcat 在 2005-12-11 23:28:42 发表的内容 可变槽距很多地方都有介绍，能否详细介绍一下可变槽深的具体技术细节（我还没找到有关这一点的介绍）？ 我发现可能我所说的“槽深”可能和开心果兄所说的不是同一样概念。我说立体声分离度不同，槽深不同，意思是： A状态：双声道母带的信号的立体声分离度比如说是80分贝，然后用这个信号直接输给刻盘机，刻出来的音槽最深处的深度比如说是a； B状态：在如上母带的基础上，在输给刻盘机之前，增加这一步：把原来的立体声信号右声道里加入一点左声道，左声道里加入一点右声道，也就是说把原来信号的声道分离度减小，比如说减小到50分贝。然后把这个信号再输给刻盘机，刻出来的音槽的最深深度比如说是b。 我的意思是：a不等于b。开心果兄说的声道分离度和槽深没有关系，应该不是指我这里说的a和b吧？

可变槽柜知道,可变槽深,不清楚,需要学习.

但最大槽深,也就是垂直方向可以刻到的最大深度,和声道分离度有直接的关系.